| Year | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Expenses | Revenue |
| 2003 Bree Cheese | 68 | 94 | .420 | 4th | 36 | 75-87 | -7 | .260 | 4.89 | | | 2,892,324 | $0 | $0 |
| 2004 Bree Cheese | 101 | 61 | .623 | 1st | - | 93-69 | 8 | .278 | 4.38 | X | | 3,418,202 | $0 | $0 |
| 2005 Bree Cheese | 100 | 62 | .617 | 1st | - | 102-60 | -2 | .289 | 4.20 | X | | 3,815,143 | $0 | $0 |
| 2006 Bree Cheese | 102 | 60 | .630 | 1st | - | 100-62 | 2 | .286 | 4.11 | X | | 3,975,480 | $0 | $0 |
| 2007 Bree Cheese | 116 | 46 | .716 | 1st | - | 109-53 | 7 | .280 | 3.80 | X | | 4,013,080 | $0 | $0 |
| 2008 Bree Cheese | 92 | 70 | .568 | 2nd | 18 | 90-72 | 2 | .260 | 4.21 | | | 4,268,032 | $0 | $0 |
| 2009 Gorgoroth Balrogs | 97 | 65 | .599 | 1st | - | 103-59 | -6 | .279 | 3.53 | X | | 4,774,152 | $0 | $0 |
| 2010 Bree Cheese | 98 | 64 | .605 | 1st | - | 97-65 | 1 | .283 | 3.98 | X | | 4,682,148 | $0 | $0 |
| 2011 Bree Cheese | 97 | 65 | .599 | 2nd | 1 | 102-60 | -5 | .283 | 3.90 | | | 4,612,438 | $0 | $0 |
| 2012 Bree Cheese | 94 | 68 | .580 | 1st | - | 93-69 | 1 | .266 | 4.16 | X | | 4,748,786 | $0 | $0 |
| 2013 Bree Cheese | 101 | 61 | .623 | 1st | - | 100-62 | 1 | .257 | 3.39 | X | | 4,284,636 | $95,572,290 | $129,124,568 |
| 2014 Bree Cheese | 104 | 58 | .642 | 1st | - | 99-63 | 5 | .272 | 3.42 | X | | 4,109,035 | $80,563,716 | $124,491,351 |
| 2015 Bree Cheese | 96 | 66 | .593 | 1st | - | 105-57 | -9 | .277 | 3.47 | X | X | 4,276,135 | $83,627,130 | $121,861,955 |
| 2016 Bree Cheese | 98 | 64 | .605 | 2nd | 4 | 100-62 | -2 | .279 | 4.06 | X | | 3,697,449 | $108,138,515 | $98,028,340 |
| 2017 Bree Cheese | 96 | 66 | .593 | 2nd | 9 | 98-64 | -2 | .283 | 3.85 | X | | 3,592,735 | $116,976,186 | $97,120,634 |
| 2018 Bree Cheese | 101 | 61 | .623 | 1st | - | 97-65 | 4 | .285 | 4.13 | X | | 3,877,845 | $101,760,409 | $102,228,279 |
| 2019 Bree Cheese | 84 | 78 | .519 | 2nd | 4 | 82-80 | 2 | .285 | 4.87 | | | 4,834,299 | $103,068,302 | $181,421,898 |
| 2020 Bree Cheese | 78 | 84 | .481 | 3rd | 23 | 83-79 | -5 | .282 | 4.91 | | | 4,833,254 | $125,366,735 | $182,486,759 |
| 2021 Bree Cheese | 82 | 80 | .506 | 3rd | 33 | 88-74 | -6 | .276 | 4.21 | | | 4,707,903 | $91,510,982 | $174,827,193 |
| 2022 Bree Cheese | 98 | 64 | .605 | 1st | - | 91-71 | 7 | .254 | 3.68 | X | | 5,073,109 | $72,653,974 | $173,167,475 |
| 2023 Bree Cheese | 93 | 69 | .574 | 2nd | 32 | 91-71 | 2 | .275 | 4.28 | X | | 4,655,656 | $86,703,391 | $176,245,036 |
| 2024 Bree Cheese | 89 | 73 | .549 | 2nd | 10 | 88-74 | 1 | .255 | 4.32 | X | | 5,194,460 | $113,328,484 | $177,693,542 |
| 2025 Bree Cheese | 84 | 78 | .519 | 3rd | 22 | 87-75 | -3 | .260 | 4.55 | | | 4,253,750 | $124,037,546 | $99,841,643 |
| Totals | 2169 | 1557 | .582 | | | 2173-1553 | -4 | .274 | 4.10 | 16 | 1 | 98,590,051 | Net: | $535,231,013 |
|
